PJ’s “small and beautiful”* celery soup from a couple of weeks ago made me want my grandmother’s similarly delicate and unassuming chicken soup.
Yields about 3 quarts
Phase 1
- 1/2 pound chicken scraps (backs, necks, wingtips, whatever)
- water to cover
- salt to taste
Put the chicken scraps in a stockpot with water to cover and salt to taste. Bring to a boil, then reduce to a simmer and cook, covered, for 30 minutes.
Phase 2
- 1 medium potato, chopped large
- 1/2 yellow onion, chopped large
- 5 medium cloves garlic, quartered
- 3 small stalks celery, chopped large
- 1 medium jalapeño (seeded and deveined if that’s your thing; I don’t), chopped large**
- 1/2 pound bone-in, proper cuts of chicken (I prefer legs and thighs); remove skins and excess fat (there’s already plenty in there)***
- juice of half a medium lime
- more salt
- a generous dash ground cumin
- lots of fresh ground black pepper
- about 3 cups more water

While Phase 1 is simmering, prepare the ingredients for Phase 2. Skim the gunk off the top, then add everything on the list above. Return to a simmer and let cook, covered, until the freshly added chicken is done (another 20-30 minutes).
Phase 3
- 1 ear corn, hacked into rounds that will just fit on a soup spoon to be nibbled at****
- 1 double handful cilantro*****
- maybe some more salt, pepper, cumin and/or lime juice, to taste

Fish the chicken out of the soup and put in the ingredients listed above, returning to a covered simmer for while you shred the proper chicken parts. Discard the bones and the chicken scraps from Phase 1. Return the shredded chicken to the pot for 5 minutes or so, and you’re done.

—
* Small and beautiful, as opposed to aiming for the TV chef goal of “bigass flavor.”
** My grandmother has ulcers and has been told not to eat spicy foods, but at least one chile always makes it in. When I asked her to describe what she put in this soup, the jalapeño was an afterthought. “Oh, and a pepper.” For flavor, of course.
*** I used boneless this time and relearned the important lesson that it cooks too fast and gets rubbery. Bone-in is the way to go. Can’t get it falling-off-the-bone tender without a bone to fall off of.
**** I may help my diners by shredding the chicken before serving (my grandmother certainly doesn’t), but the rounds of corn are non-negotiable. Nibbling them is half the fun. (For a non-summer version of this soup, just leave the corn out.)
***** Every time I rake a fork through a handful of parsley or cilantro to get the leaves off the stalks, I think of John Kraemer, who taught me that quick and easy technique.